M 311                                           Spring 2004
 
                HOMEWORK SUMMARY REPORT
 
 
Chapter number: 3
 
Section number: 1
 
Exercise number: 2
 
Number of papers received: 2
 
 
Reviewing committee: Iota
 
List all participating committee members:
    Clark, DenBleyker
 
Author(s) of paper(s) chosen for publication:
Chris Glaser
 
 
Comments: Both responses to the problem were excellent, using proper
mathematics and clearly showing the proof of each axiom.  The styles of
the responses were very different; one used mathematical symbols and
equations as explanations, while the other used fewer symbols, but also
explained the proofs very clearly in words.  Though both responses were
very well done, we believe Chris Glaser's would be the better of the two
to be published, as it is a little more explanatory than the solution of
the other author. The other author's response could possibly be used in
addition to Chris., but if only one is to be published, it should be
Chris's.  As far as mistakes go, we did not find any in either response.