M 412 Fall 2006
HOMEWORK SUMMARY REPORT
Chapter number: 2
Section number: 5
Exercise number: 6
Number of papers received: 6
Reviewing committee: Zeta
List all participating committee members:
Dakota Blair, James Burger
Author(s) of paper(s) chosen for publication:
Todd Anderson, Andrew Jannati
Comments:
Most of the solutions sumbitted to this problem were adequate. There were
a few with serious problems, but this was not a general trend. This
problem was done in class and so that may be part of the reason that so
many solutions were submitted. However, most solutions appear to follow
the discussion in class very closely and therefore it seems to indicate
that there is very little understanding of this problem beyond what was
covered in class. Therefore without going through this problem in full
detail at least once could sacrifice intuition which would make solving
similar problems difficult.
The reviewers recommend that a joint revision between t-anderson and
a-jannati be submitted implementing the specific changes mentioned in
each individual review.