M 412 Fall 2007
HOMEWORK SUMMARY REPORT
Chapter number: 10
Section number: 4
Exercise number: 3
Number of papers received: 2
Reviewing committee: alpha
List all participating committee members:
Travis Trahan, Gary Chen
Author(s) of paper(s) chosen for publication:
Part a - Altay Zhakatayev
Part b - Michael Naramore
Comments: Michael's answer includes an incorrect sign which cannot be
accounted for, but it is well written and the graphs are very nice.
Altay's explanation is correct and concise, but does not include graphs.
[...]'s paper skips many steps which suggests she does not understand
the subject.
Altay did not put his email address on his paper so his review cannot be
mailed.
INSTRUCTOR'S COMMENT: Michael's paper is published. It is correct except
for a sign that can be traced to the difference in convention (between the
book and my notes) for the exponent in the Fourier transform. His graphs
are therefore correct for the case c = -1 (not +1).